Indianapolis Theatre in May 2026

Browse the complete schedule of all shows in Indianapolis this month.
Find the best theater shows, Broadway musicals, and plays. “Indianapolis Events” is your guide to epic theatre events: Broadway shows, plays, musicals, operas, ballet performances, and other theater events to experience while in town. There’s something for everyone, from bustling Broadway shows and musicals to cozy local theater productions. Don’t miss out on indulging in the best theatre performances this month. Get theater tickets and enjoy your show worry-free.

Start Date
May 1, 2026
Reset
Cancel
Apply
End Date
May 6, 2026
Category
Search

Events Calendar
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Shows & Musicals
List Of Shows
List Of Theaters

Theater Shows & Musicals

Upcoming Shows: 90
Indianapolis, IN
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    01
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Fri
    Josh Wolf
    Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
    46225, 10 W Georgia St, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $44
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    01
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Fri
    Fiddler On The Roof
    The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts | Capacity: 500
    46032, 355 City Center Drive, Carmel, IN, US
    Prices from $99
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    01
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    Sunset Boulevard
    The Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
    Prices from $80
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Come From Away
    May
    01
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    OneAmerica Mainstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
    46204, 140 W. Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $119
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    01
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    The Phantom Tollbooth
    Hendricks Live
    46168, 200 W. Main St., Plainfield, IN, US
    Prices from $34
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    01
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Fri
    Singin' In The Rain
    Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
    46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
    Prices from $118
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    01
    2026
    9:15 PM
    Fri
    Josh Wolf
    Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
    46225, 10 W Georgia St, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $51
    Event Info
  • Come From Away
    May
    02
    2026
    5:00 PM
    Sat
    OneAmerica Mainstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
    46204, 140 W. Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $121
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    02
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Sat
    Josh Wolf
    Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
    46225, 10 W Georgia St, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $48
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    02
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Sat
    Fiddler On The Roof
    The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts | Capacity: 500
    46032, 355 City Center Drive, Carmel, IN, US
    Prices from $98
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    02
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    Sunset Boulevard
    The Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
    Prices from $80
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    02
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    Singin' In The Rain
    Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
    46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
    Prices from $102
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    02
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Sat
    The Phantom Tollbooth
    Hendricks Live
    46168, 200 W. Main St., Plainfield, IN, US
    Prices from $33
    Event Info
  • Henry Cho
    May
    02
    2026
    8:00 PM
    Sat
    Clowes Memorial Hall | Capacity: 2172
    46208, 4600 Sunset Ave, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $56
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    02
    2026
    9:30 PM
    Sat
    Josh Wolf
    Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
    46225, 10 W Georgia St, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $48
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    1:00 PM
    Sun
    Singin' In The Rain
    Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
    46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
    Prices from $96
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    2:00 PM
    Sun
    Sunset Boulevard
    The Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
    Prices from $80
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    2:00 PM
    Sun
    Machinal
    Shelton Auditorium At Butler Arts Center
    46208, 1000 W 42nd St., Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $38
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    2:00 PM
    Sun
    Fiddler On The Roof
    The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts | Capacity: 500
    46032, 355 City Center Drive, Carmel, IN, US
    Prices from $99
    Event Info
  • Come From Away
    May
    03
    2026
    2:00 PM
    Sun
    OneAmerica Mainstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
    46204, 140 W. Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $105
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    2:30 PM
    Sun
    The Phantom Tollbooth
    Hendricks Live
    46168, 200 W. Main St., Plainfield, IN, US
    Prices from $34
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    4:00 PM
    Sun
    Susan Rice
    Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
    46225, 10 W Georgia St, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $410
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    03
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Sun
    Singin' In The Rain
    Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
    46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
    Prices from $96
    Event Info
  • Come From Away
    May
    05
    2026
    6:30 PM
    Tue
    OneAmerica Mainstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
    46204, 140 W. Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $130
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Beauty And The Beast
    May
    05
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Tue
    Murat Theatre at Old National Centre | Capacity: 2600
    46204, 502 N. New Jersey St., Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $100
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    05
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Tue
    Singin' In The Rain
    Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
    46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
    Prices from $89
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    06
    2026
    1:00 PM
    Wed
    Singin' In The Rain
    Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
    46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
    Prices from $89
    Event Info
  • Beauty And The Beast
    May
    06
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Wed
    Murat Theatre at Old National Centre | Capacity: 2600
    46204, 502 N. New Jersey St., Indianapolis, IN, US
    Prices from $81
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    06
    2026
    7:30 PM
    Wed
    Sunset Boulevard
    The Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
    Prices from $80
    Limited availability
    Event Info
  • Indianapolis Event Tickets
    May
    07
    2026
    7:00 PM
    Thu
    Fiddler On The Roof
    The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts | Capacity: 500
    46032, 355 City Center Drive, Carmel, IN, US
    Prices from $99
    Event Info
Show More

List Of Theatre Shows

Fiddler On The Roof
Fiddler On The Roof
Theatre Shows: 7
The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
May 1, 2026 7:00 PM
Josh Wolf
Josh Wolf
Theatre Shows: 4
Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
May 1, 2026 7:00 PM
Singin' In The Rain
Singin' In The Rain
Theatre Shows: 20
Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
May 1, 2026 7:30 PM
Sunset Boulevard
Sunset Boulevard
Theatre Shows: 8
The Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
May 1, 2026 7:30 PM
The Phantom Tollbooth
The Phantom Tollbooth
Theatre Shows: 6
Hendricks Live
May 1, 2026 7:30 PM
Come From Away
Come From Away
Theatre Shows: 9
OneAmerica Mainstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
May 1, 2026 7:30 PM
Henry Cho
Henry Cho
Theatre Shows: 1
Clowes Memorial Hall
May 2, 2026 8:00 PM
Machinal
Machinal
Theatre Shows: 1
Shelton Auditorium At Butler Arts Center
May 3, 2026 2:00 PM
Susan Rice
Susan Rice
Theatre Shows: 1
Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
May 3, 2026 4:00 PM
Beauty and The Beast
Beauty and The Beast
Theatre Shows: 8
Murat Theatre at Old National Centre
May 5, 2026 7:00 PM
Ali Wong
Ali Wong
Theatre Shows: 1
Murat Theatre at Old National Centre
May 14, 2026 7:00 PM
Vinny Chapman - The Dancing Ump
Vinny Chapman - The Dancing Ump
Theatre Shows: 1
Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
May 14, 2026 7:30 PM
Airplane! - Show
Airplane! - Show
Theatre Shows: 1
Murat Theatre at Old National Centre
May 15, 2026 7:00 PM
Ben Bankas
Ben Bankas
Theatre Shows: 4
Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
May 15, 2026 7:30 PM
Peter Pan - Dance
Peter Pan - Dance
Theatre Shows: 4
The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
May 16, 2026 2:00 PM
Aries Spears
Aries Spears
Theatre Shows: 6
Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
May 21, 2026 7:30 PM
Romeo and Juliet - Ballet
Romeo and Juliet - Ballet
Theatre Shows: 3
The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
May 22, 2026 7:00 PM
Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella
Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella
Theatre Shows: 5
Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
May 28, 2026 7:30 PM

List Of Theaters

A-Z List Of All Theaters in the City and Indianapolis Area.
Basile Theatre at the Historic Athenaeum
location 46204, 401 East Michigan St.
Theater Shows: 1
Beef And Boards Dinner Theatre
location 46268, 9301 North Michigan Road
Theater Shows: 147
Clowes Memorial Hall
location 46208, 4600 Sunset Ave, Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 31
Egyptian Room At Old National Centre
location 46204, 502 N. New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 5
Gainbridge Fieldhouse
location 46204, 125 S. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 2
Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
location 46225, 10 W Georgia St, Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 74
Hendricks Live
location 46168, 200 W. Main St., Plainfield, IN, US
Theater Shows: 16
Howard L. Schrott Center for the Arts
location 46208, W 46th St., Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 1
Lilly Hall Studio Theatre
location 46208, 4600 Sunset Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 4
Murat Theatre at Old National Centre
location 46204, 502 N. New Jersey St., Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 25
OneAmerica Mainstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
location 46204, 140 W. Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 22
Ruoff Music Center
location 46060, 12880 E 146th St, Noblesville, IN, US
Theater Shows: 1
Shelton Auditorium At Butler Arts Center
location 46208, 1000 W 42nd St., Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 11
The Payne & Mencias Palladium At Allied Solutions Center For The Performing Arts
location 46032, 355 W. City Center Drive
Theater Shows: 4
The Studio Theater at Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
location
Theater Shows: 26
The Tarkington Theater At Allied Solutions Center for the Performing Arts
location 46032, 355 City Center Drive
Theater Shows: 28
The Tobias Theater At Newfields
location 46208, 4000 Michigan Road
Theater Shows: 4
Turntable
location 46220, 6259 N College Ave., Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 1
Upperstage - Indiana Repertory Theater
location 46204, 140 W. Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 12
Upstairs at Helium Comedy Club - Indianapolis
location 46225, 10 W. Georgia St., Indianapolis, IN, US
Theater Shows: 23
Indianapolis Events Calendar
Contact Us
VISA-Card-Secure Mastercard-Secure PayPal-Secure Amazon Pay-Secure Affirm Secure PCI DSS Compliant 256-bit Encryption Checkout SSL Secure
Independent City Events Guide

Verified listings Verified listings

Curated event schedules Curated event schedules

Impartial event information Impartial event information

Regularly updated Regularly updated

City-based event coverage City-based event coverage

Local focus Local focus on New York, NY

Verified ticket marketplaces Verified ticket marketplaces

Prices may vary Prices may vary

Independent of venues Independent of venues

Stay Updated!

Have you subscribed to Indianapolis Events on the Cheap yet? Stay up to date! Join our newsletter now to stay up to date on all Indy plus the occasional special offer and discount code! Epic events and incredible deals straight to your inbox.

Subscription Deals
Subscribe

Indianapolis.Events is an independent, city-based guide to concerts, theater, and live events in Indianapolis. We provide curated, impartial listings of upcoming performances, venues, and event schedules to help audiences discover live entertainment across the Indianapolis area. Ticket options may be available from verified marketplaces. Prices may be higher or lower than face value. Indianapolis.Events is operated by Live Entertainment Guide LLC, a U.S.-registered company that operates a network of independent, city-based live entertainment guides across the United States.

Indianapolis.Events | Sitemaps | Privacy Policy | All Rights Reserved 2026